Non-meeting of minds over mechanism of evolution

See "Take On Darwin" in "Pseudoscience" at for a non-meeting of minds in a discussion of the principles underlying the modern synthesis. I laid on a juicy banquet of arguments against natural selection and mutation being the main mechanism driving evolution but my guests were obviously reluctant to join me and delayed by endlessly discussing which doorbell to ring. I eventually withdrew my invitation.

Nice bunch, though, and I'm still auditing.